The Immediate Aftermath of a Domestic Violence Arrest
A domestic violence arrest in Florida sets into motion a fast and strict chain of events. The state’s laws and procedures reflect how seriously these cases are taken. If you or a loved one has been arrested for domestic violence (often abbreviated as “DV”), it’s critical to understand what happens next and what options exist for potentially getting the charges dropped. Drawing on our extensive experience defending domestic violence cases in South Florida, we’ll walk you through the typical process after arrest and explain strategies for a favorable outcome.
Booking and No Immediate Bond
Upon a domestic violence arrest in Florida, the accused is taken into custody and held in jail until a judge sees them, you will not be able to bond out immediately from the police station. Florida law mandates that anyone arrested for an act of domestic violence must be held in custody until brought before a court for a bail hearing. This means you will spend at least one night (often a weekend if arrested on Friday) in jail before seeing a judge. This rule exists for safety reasons, it gives the court a chance to evaluate conditions like no-contact orders before release. It can be an alarming experience, but it is standard. During booking, the charge will typically be listed as “Domestic Battery” or a related offense. In Miami-Dade and Broward, you’ll appear at the next First Appearance court session (usually within 24 hours of arrest) where a judge will address bond.
First Appearance and No-Contact Order
At the First Appearance hearing (also called bond hearing), the judge will: (1) review the arrest affidavit to determine probable cause; (2) set a bond amount (or sometimes no bond for serious cases); and crucially, (3) issue a No-Contact Order if the victim is an intimate partner or household member. Florida judges are required by law to consider the safety of the victim and any children before releasing a DV defendant. In almost all cases, a no-contact order is put in place as a condition of release. This order prohibits any direct or indirect contact with the alleged victim, no phone calls, texts, emails, social media, or asking a third party to convey a message. If you live together, you will typically be barred from returning home (at least until a subsequent court order modifies that). You may be allowed a one-time escorted visit with law enforcement to get personal belongings. Additionally, the judge may impose other conditions: for example, surrendering any firearms (federal law actually prohibits possession of guns while under a DV restraining order), abstaining from alcohol, or attending anger management classes as a condition of bond.
It’s critical to strictly abide by the no-contact order. Even if the victim wants to talk or reconcile, do not violate the order. Contacting the victim can land you back in jail on a bond revocation and new criminal charge. We’ve seen well-intentioned defendants hurt their case by a single text message saying “sorry” – it’s not worth it. The no-contact order can sometimes be revisited later (for instance, if the victim petitions to allow contact), but until you have an official modification from the court, assume it’s in full effect.
The Charges and Prosecutor’s Role
Many people believe the victim “presses charges” in a domestic violence case, but in Florida it’s the State, specifically the State Attorney’s Office, that decides what charges to file and whether to drop them. Florida has a firm “pro-prosecution” policy for domestic violence. The Legislature’s intent is that domestic violence be treated as a public crime, not a private family matter, so prosecutors are encouraged to pursue charges even if the victim has doubts or wants to drop it. After your arrest, a prosecutor will review the police reports, any 911 call recordings, photos of injuries, witness statements, etc. They may also seek input from the victim through a victim advocate.
The case might be filed as a misdemeanor (if it’s a first offense with minor injuries) or as a felony (for more serious injuries or allegations like strangulation, use of a weapon, or if you have prior DV convictions). In Florida, domestic battery by strangulation and aggravated battery are felonies, for example. Regardless of level, the court will typically route your case to a specialized domestic violence court or unit. Miami-Dade, Broward, and Palm Beach each have dedicated domestic violence court divisions with assigned judges and prosecutors who handle these cases exclusively.
One consequence of this specialization is that the prosecutors are very familiar with common defense tactics and also with victims recanting or refusing to cooperate. It’s sadly common for victims to have a change of heart after the heat of the incident passes. But prosecutors in South Florida have seen it all, they will often proceed if they believe they have evidence, even without the victim’s active participation. They can subpoena a reluctant victim or use other evidence (photos, witness testimony, excited utterance statements, etc.) to try to prove the case. The takeaway is: the decision to drop charges lies with the State, not the victim, which makes getting charges dropped more challenging but not impossible (more on that below).
Court Appearances and Updates
After first appearance, if you bond out, you will be given an arraignment date about 2–4 weeks later. At arraignment, the formal charges are read and you enter a plea (almost always “not guilty” at this stage, preserving your rights). If you have hired an attorney, often they can waive a personal appearance at arraignment and file a written plea of not guilty on your behalf. Then the case moves into the pre-trial phase. There may be several status conferences or calendar calls over the next few months. Each county is a bit different, for instance, Broward might set a “drop calendar” status where if the victim does not show interest the case could be dropped, whereas Miami typically sets trial calendars fairly quickly.
During this time, your attorney will be investigating and negotiating. They may gather favorable evidence (witness statements that you acted in self-defense, for example, or texts from the victim contradicting the allegations). They will also engage with the prosecutor to assess the case strength. Sometimes evidence like bodycam footage, 911 calls, medical reports, etc., will trickle in. Be sure to inform your lawyer of any facts that support your side (did the accuser have a motive to lie? Were there injuries on you consistent with self-defense?).
Florida law also encourages that the defendant attend counseling or intervention early if appropriate. In many jurisdictions, there are Pre-Trial Intervention (PTI) or diversion programs for domestic violence, especially for first-time offenders and less serious incidents. These typically involve completing a Batterers’ Intervention Program (BIP), community service, etc. Successful completion can result in the charges being dropped. Your attorney can advise if this is available and a good option in your case. Keep in mind, each county’s State Attorney has different policies, some are open to diversion, some less so, especially if the facts are severe.
Throughout this process, an experienced lawyer’s guidance is key to navigating the system and working towards a dismissal or reduction. Florida’s domestic violence prosecutorial units have specialized training, but so do seasoned defense attorneys who know how to find weaknesses in the state’s case and advocate for dropping or reducing the charges whenever justified.
How Can I Get the Charges Dropped?
Now to the big question: How do you get a domestic violence charge dropped in Florida? The honest answer is that there is no simple or guaranteed way – it requires convincing the State Attorney’s Office that proceeding with the case is not in the interest of justice. However, there are multiple approaches to achieve this outcome, and a combination may be used:
- Victim Input (Affidavit of Non-Prosecution): The alleged victim can state they do not want the case prosecuted. Often this is done via an Affidavit of Non-Prosecution, a written, sworn statement from the victim indicating their desire not to press charges, possibly asserting that they don’t fear the defendant or that the incident has been resolved. While such an affidavit does not automatically end the case (remember, Florida is pro-prosecution), it can be an important piece of the puzzle. Prosecutors may weigh the victim’s wishes when deciding how to proceed, especially if the case evidence is borderline. That said, be extremely careful: the defendant should never pressure or even ask the victim to do this, that could be construed as witness tampering (a felony). If the victim is inclined to drop it, they should ideally decide and act on their own or through their own attorney or victim advocate. We have represented many individuals whose partners chose to support them by making clear to prosecutors that they don’t want to testify and would prefer the case end. It can help, but it’s ultimately the State’s call.
- Self-Defense or Lack of Evidence: Florida is a Stand Your Ground state for self-defense, and that extends to domestic situations in some cases. If you were actually the one defending yourself from an attack by the other person, you have an affirmative defense. Your attorney can present evidence of self-defense to the prosecutor – for instance, photos of your injuries or eyewitness accounts that the alleged victim was the aggressor. If the evidence strongly supports self-defense, a prosecutor may drop charges rather than try to overcome that at trial. In some cases, we can even file a Stand Your Ground motion to have a judge grant immunity under Florida’s self-defense immunity law (meaning the case would be dismissed pre-trial if the judge finds you acted in self-defense). Additionally, if the state’s overall evidence is weak, say the victim gave conflicting stories, or there’s no corroborating evidence of any injury or disturbance, your attorney can highlight these problems. Prosecutors know that if they can’t prove the case beyond a reasonable doubt at trial, they should consider dropping it. Sometimes a well-crafted defense packet (including witness statements, character letters, or the victim’s non-prosecution affidavit) sent to the State Attorney can persuade them to “nolle prosse” (drop) the charge.
- Completion of Intervention Programs: Many Florida jurisdictions have informal or formal programs that if the defendant preemptively completes, the prosecutor might agree to drop or greatly reduce the charges. For example, voluntarily enrolling in and completing an anger management or Batterers’ Intervention Program (BIP) can demonstrate to the prosecutor and court that you are addressing the underlying issues. In some first-offender cases, prosecutors will essentially hold the case in abeyance while you attend counseling, and if you show proof of completion (and no further incidents), they will dismiss the case. These arrangements might not be officially called “diversion,” but function similarly. Additionally, if alcohol or substance abuse was a factor in the incident, attending AA/NA meetings or substance abuse counseling can be part of convincing them you’re taking responsibility and the situation will not recur. Our experience has shown that proactive steps by the defendant often make a huge difference in outcomes, it gives the prosecutor a reason to justify dropping a case (“the defendant has voluntarily gotten help, so justice is served without prosecution”). Always coordinate with your attorney on this; you want to ensure any program you do will be recognized and worthwhile in the eyes of the court.
- Negotiating a Lesser Charge or Withholding Adjudication: Sometimes getting a “drop” is achieved indirectly. The State might be reluctant to drop a domestic battery entirely, especially if there were injuries. But they might agree to reduce it to a lesser offense (like simple battery or disorderly conduct) with an agreement that if you meet certain conditions, even that charge gets dismissed eventually. Florida law allows for withhold of adjudication on certain charges, meaning you wouldn’t be formally convicted even if you plead guilty, and you may be eligible to seal your record after. While this isn’t the same as an immediate dropping of charges, it effectively avoids a conviction and can be presented as a win-win: the State resolves the case and you avoid a record. For example, we’ve had DV cases recharged as “disorderly conduct” and the client do a diversion program, after which the charge was dismissed. It’s not the pure drop in the early stage, but the end result is similar. A skilled attorney knows how to structure such deals and present them to the prosecution as a reasonable alternative to trial.
- Trial (the Last Resort to “Drop”): Of course, if all else fails, you have the right to go to trial and require the State to prove its case. If they cannot (e.g., if the victim refuses to testify and they lack other evidence), you may be acquitted, which is effectively the charges being thrown out by a jury. Prosecutors often reassess cases as the trial date nears, especially if their key witness (the victim) is uncooperative or has credibility issues. We have seen cases dropped on the eve of trial for this reason. Trial is stressful and uncertain, so it’s usually a last resort, but the willingness to take a case to trial often strengthens your negotiating position. A prosecutor who knows the defense is ready and the evidence is iffy may choose to cut their losses and drop it rather than risk a not-guilty verdict. Thus, having an attorney unafraid of trial can indirectly lead to a dismissal without trial.
A Note on Victim Cooperation and Pressure
Florida authorities are aware that in domestic cases, victims might be pressured by defendants or family to drop the case. Any hint of harassment or intimidation toward the victim will backfire badly, it can lead to new charges and virtually zero chance of the original case being dropped. On the other hand, if the victim on their own decides they want to support the defendant (for instance, they speak to the defendant’s attorney or victim advocate and say the incident was a one-time mistake, etc.), that can help. Victims also have the right to request the court dismiss an injunction if one was put in place, but that’s separate from the criminal case (and usually, judges wait until the criminal case is resolved to address injunctions). The key is: any victim cooperation in favor of the defense must be voluntary and genuine. Prosecutors and judges will often question the victim privately to ensure they aren’t being coerced. If the victim’s stance is that they want no prosecution, that’s an important factor, though not decisive.
Focus on Defense: Experience Matters
At George Law, we bring authoritative knowledge of Florida’s domestic violence laws – for instance, we know that Florida law requires special units of prosecutors for DV cases and favors prosecution even over a victim’s objection, as discussed above. This means a strategic defense is needed to get charges dropped. Our attorneys leverage experience such as former prosecutor insight to identify when a case might quietly be dropped due to evidentiary issues, and when aggressive defense tactics are needed. Trustworthiness is built by being candid with our clients: if the evidence is strong, we’ll focus on mitigation and reduction; if it’s weak, we’ll push hard for dismissal.
It’s worth noting the emotional aspect too – a domestic violence arrest often involves family or someone you love. We recognize the desire to reconcile or explain. Part of our guidance is helping defendants navigate restraining orders, child visitation issues, and the collateral consequences during the case. Staying out of further legal trouble while the case is pending is vital. Keeping the peace and complying with court orders actually improves the odds that a prosecutor will eventually agree to drop or reduce the charges, because it shows the incident truly might have been isolated.
____________________________________________________________________________
Don’t navigate this complex legal territory alone. If you’re facing domestic violence charges, contact the qualified and experienced attorneys at George Law today for the expert legal defense you deserve.
FAQs: Florida Domestic Violence Arrests and Dropping Charges
Q1: Can the victim drop the charges by telling the police or prosecutor they don’t want to press charges?
Not directly. In Florida, once an arrest is made, the State Attorney controls the case, not the victim. The victim’s wishes are considered but are not decisive. A victim can sign a decline to prosecute affidavit (also called an Affidavit of Non-Prosecution) which informs the State of their desire to drop the case. This can carry weight, especially if the case is borderline or the victim insists nothing happened. However, due to Florida’s pro-prosecution policy for domestic violence, prosecutors may still continue if they believe a crime occurred – they might feel the victim is under pressure or at risk. In practice, cases are more likely to be dropped if the victim is uncooperative and the evidence is weak. While a victim cannot single-handedly “drop” charges, their lack of participation can make it hard for the State to proceed, which may lead to a dismissal down the line.
Q2: What happens if the victim tries to contact me or reconcile while the no-contact order is in place?
You must not engage in any contact until the court modifies the order, no matter who initiates it. The no-contact order binds you (the defendant), not the victim. Even if the victim calls you and says they want to reconcile or apologize, you are prohibited from responding. The proper course is to inform your attorney. In some cases, if the victim truly wants contact, they can appear in court or file a motion to modify the no-contact order (for example, to allow peaceful contact or communication for child exchange). Only a judge can change the order. Until that happens, any interaction is a violation on your part. Many South Florida judges explicitly warn defendants: “I don’t care if he/she calls you – you cannot respond.” Violating the no-contact order is a separate misdemeanor that can land you back in jail and significantly hurt your chances of a favorable outcome on the original case. So as hard as it may be, you must politely decline or ignore any contact from the victim while the order is active. Let the lawyers handle any necessary communications through proper legal channels.
Q3: If the victim isn’t cooperating with prosecutors, will my case automatically be dismissed?
Not automatically, but it could be eventually. Prosecutors can and do proceed without cooperative victims, using other evidence. However, if the victim refuses to testify or has disappeared, and there is insufficient independent evidence (no other witnesses, no excited 911 call on record, minimal injury, etc.), the State may have no choice but to drop the case. That decision often happens on the eve of trial. Prosecutors might keep the case open for a while hoping the victim comes around or they find other proof. We’ve handled cases where a girlfriend-victim didn’t want to go forward; the State still pushed the case for months, but ultimately, on the trial date, they dropped it because they couldn’t prove it without her testimony. Each situation is unique – for instance, if there is a 911 recording capturing the incident or excited utterances, they might try to use that in lieu of live testimony (under certain evidence rules). Non-cooperation is a big hurdle for the State, but they won’t admit defeat immediately. Your attorney can gauge how crucial the victim’s testimony is and may be able to expedite a dismissal if it’s clear the case can’t proceed without them. But expect prosecutors to attempt to save the case if they can, given Florida’s stance on domestic violence.
Q4: Is there a way to get the domestic violence charge off my record if it’s dropped?
Yes. If your case is dropped (formally “nolle prosequi” or dismissed) or you’re acquitted, you are generally eligible to have the record expunged in Florida, provided you have no prior convictions and no other disqualifying factors. An expungement would remove the arrest record from public databases, so background checks would not show the charge. If instead you enter a plea and receive a withhold of adjudication on a domestic violence charge, note that under Florida law, you cannot seal a record of a domestic violence offense even with a withhold – the law specifically prohibits sealing records of domestic violence matters that resulted in a plea (this is different from many other charges). So the best way to clear your record is indeed to get the charge dropped or win at trial, then expunge. This is another reason it can be crucial to fight for a dismissal if employment or reputation is a concern. The expungement process is a separate legal proceeding after the case; our firm regularly guides clients through that once we achieve a drop. Keep in mind you only get one expungement in a lifetime (with some exceptions), so using it on a DV arrest is worthwhile if that’s your only blemish.
Q5: Do I really need a lawyer for a first-time domestic battery? Can’t I just go to court and explain it was a misunderstanding?
It is strongly recommended to have a lawyer. Domestic violence cases are taken very seriously in Florida. If you go alone and simply tell the judge “it was a misunderstanding,” not only will that not get the case dropped, it could be used against you as an admission. Anything you say in court is on record. Without a lawyer, you might also miss opportunities to get evidence that could exonerate you (such as obtaining security camera footage or text messages) before it’s lost. A lawyer can negotiate with prosecutors and navigate the legal system – for example, steering you into a diversion program that you might not even know about as a layperson. Additionally, an attorney can file motions to potentially dismiss the case or suppress evidence, or in some instances seek a Stand Your Ground immunity hearing (Florida allows a motion to dismiss if you acted in self-defense reasonably). These legal strategies are very hard to successfully pull off without professional representation. Finally, having a lawyer shows the State you are taking the matter seriously – a prosecutor may be more willing to negotiate or drop a borderline case if they see you’ve retained competent counsel who will fight it hard. In sum, the cost of a lawyer is an investment in protecting your record, freedom, and future. Domestic violence convictions carry stigma and collateral consequences (like inability to possess firearms, impact on custody of children, etc.). With so much at stake, exercising your right to an attorney is the wise choice.
